By Victoria Winterberg | Winterberg Law Firm | El Paso, TX
For many years, if USCIS denied your immigration application, the worst thing that usually happened was that your case was denied. You could appeal, file again, or, if you had no other options, leave the country without facing a formal case in immigration court.
That is no longer how it works.
Since February 2025, USCIS has been operating under a new policy that significantly expands the circumstances in which it will issue a Notice to Appear (NTA), the legal document that initiates a deportation case in immigration court. What once ended with a simple denial can now become something much more serious.
If you have a pending case, are thinking about filing an application, or have a family member in the immigration system, this is something you need to understand.
What Is a Notice to Appear?
A Notice to Appear, commonly called an NTA, is a formal charging document issued by the Department of Homeland Security that places you in removal proceedings before an immigration judge. In plain terms, it is the government saying it wants to deport you, and now you have to go to court to defend yourself.
Receiving an NTA does not automatically mean you will be deported. Many people who receive one have legal options, such as asylum, cancellation of removal, adjustment of status, protection under VAWA, or other forms of immigration relief. But it does mean your situation has become considerably more complicated, more expensive, and much more time-sensitive. And if you miss your court date, a judge may order your removal in absentia, which carries a 10-year penalty that blocks most immigration benefits.
What Changed in February 2025
On February 28, 2025, USCIS issued a policy memorandum titled “Issuance of Notices to Appear in Cases Involving Inadmissible and Deportable Aliens.” The memorandum removed many of the protections that had previously limited when USCIS could initiate a deportation case.
Under the previous policy, many applicants whose cases were denied could simply move forward without being placed in formal removal proceedings. Under the new policy, that is no longer the norm. USCIS has been instructed to issue an NTA whenever an immigration benefit is denied and the person no longer has lawful immigration status, and to stop treating any group of immigrants as automatically exempt from immigration enforcement.
The policy was subsequently reinforced by additional updates to the USCIS Policy Manual in July 2025.
Who Is at Greater Risk?
Not every denial will result in an NTA. USCIS still has some discretion, and the policy focuses mainly on specific situations. Here is where the risk is greatest:
You Are Out of Status When Your Case Is Denied.
This is the most common reason. If your visa has already expired, your parole authorization has ended, or you have no other valid immigration status when USCIS denies your application, an NTA is very likely to be issued. Even a short period out of status can create this risk.
Your Application Involved Fraud or Misrepresentation.
USCIS will issue an NTA whenever there is evidence of fraud in the record, even if fraud was not the official reason for the denial and even if you withdraw your application before a decision is made. This includes false statements made anywhere in the application by anyone involved.
You Have a Criminal Record.
If you have been arrested, charged, or convicted of a crime, even many years ago, and your application for an immigration benefit is denied, USCIS will likely issue an NTA and refer your case to immigration enforcement authorities.
Your Naturalization Case Reveals a Past Problem.
If you apply for citizenship and USCIS determines that you were not actually eligible for permanent residence when it was granted, whether because of fraud, misrepresentation, or a criminal issue, USCIS will issue an NTA. This can happen even to people who have held permanent residence for many years.
Your I-751 Petition to Remove Conditions on Residence Is Denied.
If you have conditional permanent residence, the kind granted when you have been married for less than two years, and your I-751 is denied, an NTA will automatically follow.
What Does This Mean Before You File an Application?
The most important change created by this policy is something many people do not consider: filing an immigration application now carries more risk than it did before.
In the past, the main consequence of a denied application was simply the loss of time and money. Now, depending on your circumstances, a denial could trigger a deportation case. That does not mean you should not apply. It means you should not do so without first fully understanding your situation.
Before applying for any immigration benefit, especially adjustment of status, an I-751, or naturalization, it is worth sitting down with an attorney and honestly reviewing your history. That includes discussing anything that could be considered problematic:
Criminal history, previous immigration violations, how you obtained your status in the past, or any situation that a government officer might view differently from the way you do.
The goal is not to scare you away from filing. The goal is to make sure that, if a risk exists, you know about it before USCIS discovers it.
Practical Steps to Protect Yourself
Keep Your Immigration Status Current.
The most effective way to reduce the risk of receiving an NTA is not to let your immigration status expire while your case is pending. File renewals and extensions well before your current status ends.
Be Completely Honest on Every Application.
Fraud and misrepresentation are a direct path to an NTA, even if your case would otherwise have been approvable. If there is something complicated in your history, consult an attorney about how to disclose it properly, not whether to disclose it.
Do Not Withdraw an Application Assuming That Will Protect You.
Under the new policy, withdrawing your application does not prevent USCIS from issuing an NTA if there is evidence of fraud in the record.
If You Receive an NTA, Do Not Ignore It.
Contact an attorney immediately. Missing your first court hearing, known as the Master Calendar Hearing, will result in an automatic removal order issued in your absence. That order can follow you for a decade and close off most paths to lawful status.
Check Your Court Date Yourself.
If you receive an NTA, your hearing date may or may not appear on the document. You can verify it by calling the EOIR automated hotline at 1-800-898-7180 and using your A-number. Do not assume you will receive a reminder. You can also visit https://acis.eoir.justice.gov/en/ and enter your A-number to find the date of your next hearing.
If You Receive a Notice to Appear, You Have Options
An NTA is serious. But receiving one does not mean the end of your case or your life here. Depending on your situation, you may qualify for cancellation of removal, adjustment of status through a family petition, asylum or withholding of removal, protection under VAWA, or voluntary departure. The key is to act quickly and work with an attorney who handles immigration court cases, not only applications before USCIS.
Frequently Asked Questions
My Case Is Pending and My Visa Expired While I Was Waiting. Am I at Risk?
Potentially, yes. If USCIS denies your case while you are out of status, the new policy places you among those most likely to receive an NTA. This is one of the most important reasons to consult an attorney before that happens; there may still be steps you can take to reduce the risk.
I Filed an Application on My Own and Am Not Sure Everything Was Completed Correctly. What Should I Do?
Contact an attorney and have your application reviewed before USCIS makes a decision. If there are errors or omissions, an experienced immigration attorney can advise you whether and how to correct them. Trying to fix things yourself or ignoring the problem is much riskier than getting legal guidance.
I Have Permanent Residence and Am Applying for Citizenship. Can USCIS Really Issue an NTA at This Stage?
Yes. USCIS now issues NTAs in naturalization cases when it determines that the applicant was inadmissible at the time permanent residence was granted, even if that happened years ago. If you have any concerns about your history, speak with an attorney before filing your N-400.
I Already Have a Pending Case. Is It Too Late to Hire an Attorney?
It is never too late to obtain legal representation, but the sooner, the better. If your case is still pending, there may be steps we can take to strengthen it or address potential problems before a decision is made. Call us, and we will explain where your case stands.
We Are Here to Help
Winterberg Law Firm handles both USCIS matters and immigration court cases. If you have a pending case, are planning to file an application, or have received an NTA and do not know what to do next, call us. We will be straightforward with you about your situation and your options.
915-841-9777 | victoria@winterberglawfirm.com | epimmigrationlawyer.com
Victoria Winterberg is a licensed immigration attorney and owner of Winterberg Law Firm in El Paso, Texas. This post is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Immigration laws change frequently, and every case is different. Contact our office to discuss your specific situation.